Faith's Double
by Faithful_chickie
Rating: NC-17
Disclaimer: These characters are the property of Joss Whedon. Missy
Pantone is the property Jessica Bendinger and Universal Pictures.
Notes: Buffy/Missy - BTVS & Bring It On Crossover.
This was Missy's first day. She felt lucky that most of the teachers had allowed her late registration, and now she was sitting in one of the most popular professor's classes. *Sunnydale may not be so bad after all.* She smiled as she leaned back in her chair, waiting for the class to fill and start.
The other students began wandering in. Missy noticed a very cute blonde and a red head stroll in. The blonde was very excited and talking in an extremely animated manner. It struck Missy as adorable. Intrigued, she leaned forward for a better view of the petite blonde.
"So are you ready for Psych class today?" Willow asked, approaching Buffy in the hall.
"Oh hey, Wil. Yep, I'm all read up and rearing to go... or something like that." The little slayer chuckled as she followed the red head into the room.
"How was slaying last night?" Willow asked, making her way to their usual seats.
"Oh! You'd never believe it!" Buffy went into a very descriptive explanation of the previous evening's encounter. They failed to notice the beautiful brunette watching them with great interest.
Missy picked up her books and moved to a closer seat. She could have sworn the hyper one said something about vampires.
Willow laughed as she sat down and glanced around. The brunette finally caught her eye. She paled perceptibly. Missy tried a friendly smile, but the red head continued to scowl.
"Buffy." Willow grabbed her arm. "Don't turn around, but Faith's here."
Professor Walsh walked in. "Good morning class, I trust you've done the reading."
Buffy slowly turned to see what Willow was looking at. Missy grinned at the funny blonde. *Damn, she's cute!*
The slayer wrinkled her brow in confusion. She leaned near the witch and whispered. "That's not Faith."
"What do you mean?! Of course, it's Faith. Buffy, look at her!" Willow became agitated.
"Wil, I'm telling you. That's not Faith. She may look exactly like her, but it's not her. Slayer senses, remember?" Buffy gestured.
"Excuse me. Miss Summers is there something you'd like to share?" Professor Walsh's tone was one of irritation.
"Um.. no." The slayer blushed as the rest of the class guffawed. Missy was hooked. She spent the entire class watching the cute blonde, trying to think of a reason to talk to her afterwards.
Occasionally Buffy stole a peek at the Faith look-alike, and every time she found the girl staring at her. It was unnerving. *What right does she have to look exactly like Faith?! And why is she looking at me like that?!*
The class ended and before Missy could gather her books, the little blonde had approached her.
"Hi, you must be new here. I'm Buffy." The slayer held out her hand. Missy smiled and took it gently in her own.
"Missy. Missy Pantone. And you are?" The brunette turned toward Willow.
"Oh that's my friend, Willow. We were just going to get some coffee. Would you like to come with us?" Buffy stared, amazed by the resemblance.
"Normally that would be great, but I have another class. Thanks anyway." She tried to head for the door, but the slayer still held her hand.
"Maybe some other time." Buffy nervously suggested. She didn't want to let go of Missy's hand.
The brunette glanced down and smirked. "Um... B, I'm gonna need my hand back."
"What did you just call me?" Buffy's jaw dropped.
"Oh.. Sorry. It's a bad habit. I tend to give people nicknames. You just seemed like a little bee buzzing around when came into the room." Missy gave her a winning smile then gently pulled her hand away. "I really have to go, but if you want to get coffee or something later, you can call me." The brunette quickly scribbled a number down and handed it to Buffy. "I'm in Stevenson Hall."
"So are we." The little blonde perked up, excited.
"Well then I'll definitely be seeing you. Call me if you want to get together." Missy waved as she left. The witch and slayer watched her until she disappeared around the corner.
"Why would you want anything to do with her?" Willow asked, baffled by Buffy's invitation.
"I know she's not Faith, but don't you think we should still find out more about her?"
"Good point." Willow nodded and followed after the her best friend.
Buffy paced back and forth, holding the piece of paper with Missy's phone number. She wanted to call but was too nervous. *Missy looks exactly like Faith. She even has dimples like Faith.* Buffy smiled at the memory. *Missy's gorgeous... Ugh! Why am I so nervous?! All I have to do is call and say 'hey, let's get some coffee' or 'hey, it's me Buffy. Remember, B... buzz, buzz.' Ugh! No. That's so dorky.*
The tense slayer continued to pace until Willow came in behind her. "Buf, what are you doing?"
Buffy spun around embarrassed. "Um... nothing. Just thinking."
The red head went and sat on her bed, setting down her books. "This wouldn't have anything to do with Faith's double, would it?"
"No.... Okay, maybe. I don't know. Wil, she looks exactly like Faith. How's that possible?!"
"Maybe they're twins." Willow suggested with a shrug.
"No, Faith didn't say that she had a sister. We have to find out more." Buffy turned to the witch. "Can you hack into the school records? Find out everything you can about this Missy Pantone? Where'd she come from? Who are her parents? And find out what room she's in. We know she's in Stevenson Hall."
Willow nodded as she opened up her laptop and went online.
"Got it." Willow sang out just as there was a knock at the door. Buffy went to answer it.
"Hey." The little slayer looked over her shoulder at Willow who quickly closed her laptop.
"Hi Buffy. You didn't call so I thought I'd just stop by and see if you still wanted to get that coffee. I'm on my way out so if you wanna come." Missy tilted her head slightly and grinned in that charming Faithy way.
Buffy blinked back her surprise. *She even grins like Faith.* "Well, yeah. Sure. I'm up for it." The blonde turned back toward Willow. "Wil, do you want to come with?"
"No. I have a test to study for but thanks." The red head signaled that Buffy should go, and she'd finish their research.
"Okay, just let me get my coat." Buffy gestured for Missy to come in. "So where did you go to high school?"
"Rancho Carne High School in San Diego but I'm from L.A. more or less. I was born in Boston though. How about you?" Missy gave Willow a friendly smile while she waited.
"I went to Sunnydale High. My mother and I moved here from L.A." Buffy grabbed a jacket and waved goodbye to Willow. "I'll be back in a few hours, Wil."
"So where do you want to go? It's still pretty early." The brunette glanced around, unaware of Buffy's close scrutiny.
*God, she's unbelievably gorgeous.* "Huh? Oh sorry. Uh... We could go to the Espresso Pump." The little slayer suggested blushing as Missy smiled at her.
"You know you're so totally cute, don't you?" The brunette laughed as Buffy blushed harder.
"Um... No. But I know you're very pretty." The slayer kicked herself mentally. *Ugh! What a stupid thing to say! She's going to think you're totally creepy! Summers, you idiot!*
"Really? You think so?" Missy teased, grinning. "Come on little B." She held the door open for Buffy. The slayer giggled and walked in. "So you're from L.A.?" Missy tried to make conversation.
"Yes. But it seems so long ago. Tell me about Boston." The blonde asked as she glanced at the menu.
"There's not much to tell. I don't remember anything about it. I just know that's where my parents adopted me from. Cliff was adopted in New York." Missy and Buffy ordered and sat down.
"Cliff?"
"My brother. He's going to ASU. Don't ask me why. Arizona... yuck!" Missy scrunched up her nose in distaste. They both laughed.
Buffy suddenly looked uncertain. She wanted to ask another question but wasn't sure if it was impolite.
"What's wrong?" Missy cocked her head, studying the adorable blonde.
"Oh, nothing. I just was wondering. I mean, you said you were adopted... I was wondering..." Buffy hesitated.
"Go ahead. You can ask me anything." Missy gave her a reassuring smile.
"Do you know if you had a sister?" Buffy peered up at her, concerned that she may have hit a soft spot when Missy's expression changed.
"How did you know that?"
"So you did? You had a twin sister, didn't you?" Buffy's eyes lit up.
"Again. How did you know that?!" Missy became agitated.
"I've met her." Buffy stated matter-of-factly.
"WHAT?!" The brunette stood up. "You know Faith?!"
"Yes." The little slayer now wondered at the wisdom of telling Missy like this. "Missy, I'm sorry. I didn't mean to upset you."
"No. It's just a shock that's all." The dark-eyed beauty sat back down. "Faith and I were separated so long ago. My parents were never able to find her. She just disappeared."
"What do you mean?" Buffy asked carefully. She didn't want to excite the young girl any further. As it was, she already felt pretty cruel for telling her like this.
"Well, our mother was a psycho, drug-addict. She gave us up for adoption when we were four. My parents adopted both of us." Missy paused.
"I don't understand." Buffy gently touched Missy's shoulder. "Then why..." It suddenly dawned on Buffy.
"Our birth mother changed her mind. She tried to kidnap us both. She got Faith, and we never saw her again." Tears rolled down Missy's cheeks.
"I'm so sorry. Really I am." Buffy tried to comfort her.
"No. It's okay. It was so long ago. I just haven't thought about it. I try not to. I miss her still." The brunette brushed away the tears and looked closely at Buffy. "Where's my sister?"
"We should go back to the dorm. I'll explain there." Buffy grabbed their coffees and guided her out.
"Look, that was really insensitive of me. I'm sorry." The slayer turned to face Missy. "I mean, tact would have been nice." She lowered her head.
Missy grinned. *God, this girl is amazing.* The brunette reached to cup Buffy's chin and tip her face up. "It's okay, B. You couldn't have known the circumstances. I'm glad you told me. I knew there was something so special about you. And that coincidence confirms it." She gazed into the beautiful green pools of Buffy's eyes. They both froze, stunned by the current they felt between them.
Buffy was entranced. She just wanted... wanted to kiss Missy. Shaking it off, she stepped back. "Good. I mean, I'm glad you're not mad at me. But we really should go. It's not safe around here at night."
Missy chuckled. "Don't worry B. I'd protect you." They became silent again as Missy leaned forward and tenderly kissed Buffy. The super slayer swooned under the ex-cheerleader's soft and experienced lips.
The kiss was so gentle and delicious. When Missy slowly pulled back Buffy's eyes were still closed. The petite blonde sighed and giggled. "Uhhh... huh?" Then she swayed slightly.
Missy laughed and caught her. "You are so cute! Damn, wait till I tell Torrance. She won't believe that I met someone as cute as her." The brunette chuckled slightly. "Don't mind me. It's a joke Torrance and I have."
"Who's Torrance?" Buffy asked suddenly jealous.
"My best friend and my brother's girlfriend, we were on the cheerleading squad together." Missy rolled her eyes. "I know. Don't say it."
"YOU WERE ON THE CHEERLEADING SQUAD?!" Buffy's eyes got big as she grinned. *How sexy! She's a cheerleader!*
"SHHH... B, I told you... shhh... It's not like I'm too proud of it." Missy gently poked Buffy. "Big mouth."
"I think it's great. I kissed a cheerleader." Buffy squealed, jumping up and down. "Wait `til I tell Willow that you were on cheer. She'll tease me endlessly about it."
"Or you could just keep your big mouth shut." Missy grabbed Buffy and swung her around. "Hmmm? What do you say short stuff? Are you going to keep my dirty little secret?" She laughed as she held her tight.
They both stopped and gazed at each other. Buffy leaned in and kissed her. The same sparks shot through both them. "Oh god..." Buffy groaned as she stepped back. "I never knew kissing could feel so good."
"Maybe you haven't been doing it right." Missy grinned and took Buffy's hand. "Let's take this somewhere more private, what do you say?" She tugged the other girl along. "Then you can tell me where Faithy is?"
Buffy's face fell. Missy stopped in her tracks. "WHAT?! WHAT IS IT?!" The brunette covered her face with her hands. "She's dead, isn't she?!"
"NO! Missy, she's not dead. I'm sorry to scare you like that. It's just that... well, there's a lot to tell you... You see, we're sla..." Before Buffy could finish the sentence two vampires jumped them.
"Holy shit!" Missy shouted as she did a flip and dodged the one gunning for her. "BUFFY!" She dove toward the blonde, alarmed by the punch that Buffy had absorbed. "You Motherfuckers! I'll kill you!" The brunette did a spinning kick and knocked the vampire back.
The other vampire screamed. "It's the two slayers! Let's get out of here!"
"Not so fast!" Buffy plunged the stake into his companion while Missy did a backhanded spring and kick. She knocked the remaining vampire to the ground. The slayer rushed over and plunged a branch into his chest. He became a cloud of dust.
Missy stared at her for a moment. "Was that a ... a .."
"A vampire." Buffy blinked back her shock as Missy fainted. The little blonde quickly caught her and lifted her in her arms. "Sorry Missy. I guess that was kind of the icing on the cake for you, huh?" Buffy snorted as she cradled the unconscious cheerleader in her arms. "Nice moves though; you might have some slayer in you after all. But this fainting stuff, Missy... has to go." Buffy chuckled again as she carried the girl toward their dorm.
"Wil, is she going to be alright?" Buffy hovered over the beautiful brunette, concerned.
"Yes, just let her come to naturally." The wiccan turned back toward her friend. "So tell me again, what happened?"
"We were jumped by a couple of vampires."
"No, not that. Tell me about you and her and this kissing thing." Willow gave her a mischievous grin. "So are you going to break it off with Riley?"
"Oh my god! Riley! I forgot about Riley!" Buffy ran her hands nervously through her tangled locks. "Argh! Wil, what am I going to do? Riley, is a great guy, but..." The slayer turned back toward Missy. "I can't explain it. Kissing her was... amazing. I'm so drawn to her. She's so incredible... It's like she has all the fire and energy of Faith but without the crazy and evil. She's like the perfect Faith." Buffy began to pace, trying to find the words to explain to Willow. "You see, I cared about Faith, but everything got so screwed up. And now... now she's in jail."
Willow shook her head. "Buffy, but Missy isn't Faith. You can't care for her because they look alike."
"No. I don't. I like Missy." Buffy turned around and smiled. "And her looking like Faith... that just makes it absolutely perfect." Her green eyes sparkled.
The witch laughed. "I believe someone's got a crush. A major crush! Look at you Buffy, you're all glowy." Willow hugged her. "I'm happy for you."
They both went back over to Buffy's bed. The luscious brunette still lay peacefully. The little slayer gently caressed her cheek. "Missy... Missy, wake up."
Slowly, the thick lashes fluttered and Buffy was gazing into the darkest, most beautiful eyes that she'd ever seen.
"Buffy.. what happened?"
"Shhh... it's okay, Missy. We're back in my dorm room." She turned to look at Willow for guidance. The red head took the cue and came over.
"Hey Missy. How are you doing? Buffy, told me that you two were jumped." The witch held out a glass of water.
"Oh thanks Red." Missy accepted the drink politely. She was still dazed.
Buffy and Willow exchanged a surprised look at Missy's choice of nicknames. She was so much like Faith it was uncanny.
"Do you remember any of it?" Buffy sat at the end of the bed.
"Yeah, it was freaky weird. They were vampires." Missy gasped, glancing at Buffy for confirmation.
"Yep, they were. It's time I tell you everything. Get comfortable because there's a lot we have to go over."
By the time Buffy was finished explaining, Missy had a perplexed expression on her face.
"And all of this is true?" She glanced from Buffy to Willow. They both nodded.
"Missy, you don't hate me because of Faith, do you?" Buffy asked worriedly.
"No... No, of course not. My sister always had a wilder side." Missy chuckled sadly. "But I want you understand, it's not really all her fault. You have to realize that things were really bad with our birth mother. Heck, that could have been me." The brunette looked down guiltily. "In some ways, I was glad that our mother took Faith and not me. I feel like such a creep. Faith's had it so rough. I'm sorry for what she did to both of you. I know my little sis didn't mean it."
"Little sis?" Buffy raised an eyebrow.
"I'm the older one... by a few minutes."
Willow and Buffy smiled. It sounded so cute. The red head tilted her head and studied Missy. *Buffy is right. She's like an awesome version of Faith. Faith without the insane.* Willow liked her.
"So Buffy tells me that you're a cheerleader." The wiccan smirked. "It's so Cordelia of you."
"Buffy! That was our secret, remember?!" Missy picked Buffy up, tossing her onto the bed. She began tickling the slayer. "You've got a big mouth for such a little girl." They all laughed as Buffy screamed for help through her giggles.
"Sorry, Buffy. You brought this on yourself." Willow folded her arms over her chest.
"No fair! I save you when you need saving." The put-upon blonde gasped between laughs. Willow rolled her eyes and made a half hearted effort.
"Missy, you don't want to keep doing that. She might pee in her pants."
The brunette grinned. "Little B, are you going to wet your bed?" She pinned Buffy and kissed her. The kiss was meant to be playful, but by the time they were done Willow even felt the heat.
Missy broke the kiss and stepped away from the blonde. "I'm sorry Red. That was kinda rude."
The red head shrugged, but was obviously embarrassed. "It's okay. I have to head over to Tara's anyway. I'm staying over there so I'll see you two in class tomorrow." She waved as she made a hasty retreat.
Missy turned back towards Buffy. "Oops. I think we freaked her out."
"Nawww, Willow's gay. She's just wigged because it's me kissing a girl. She'll get use to it though." The blonde smiled and leaned forward to steal another kiss.
"Oh really? Plan on kissing a lot of girls, do you?" The ex- cheerleader teased, tapping Buffy lightly on the nose.
"Nope, just you." Buffy suddenly blushed when she realized how that sounded. "I mean, um... if you want to be kissing me that is... or if we see each other more and there's kissing... I mean,..." Missy stopped her babbling with another kiss.
"I have an idea." The brunette wiggled her eyebrows.
"What?" Buffy became nervous.
The dark-eyed beauty sauntered over to the door and opened it. "Let's have some fun. You wanna go up to my room and have a few drinks. I have several bottles of really good wine that have just been begging to get drank up. Hmmm? Whaddya say B?"
"Okay." Buffy spoke hesitantly. Her and alcohol didn't really mix, but she didn't want to look uptight to Missy. She could drink a bit. There was no harm in that, right?
"Get into your pjs and you can just sleep upstairs with me. I have a single." Missy bragged, leaning back on her heels.
"Geez, a single. Must be nice." The slayer realized what she said. "Oh, don't get me wrong. I love having Wil as a roomate but sometimes..."
"Yep, I know... privacy." The brunette laughed. "Now come on, hurry up. We don't have all night."
Buffy went into the bathroom and changed while Missy waited. "Okay, I'm ready." The little blonde bounced out smiling.
Missy arched an eyebrow. "Are you?" She teased, enjoying the dark blush that crept over Buffy's perfect features.
A few minutes later Buffy was sitting on Missy's bed as the brunette poured her a glass of wine. "Drink away. I'm going to get changed."
Buffy's eyes went wide when the ex-cheerleader began stripping in front of her. She took a large sip of her wine and coughed. "Um... not shy, are we?"
"Should I be?" The dark-eyed beauty turned around to face Buffy as she removed her bra. "Don't you like my body?"
Buffy choked again. "I... uh... um..."
"Shhhh... It's cool B. Here." Missy strolled over to where the slayer sat perched. Her breasts were eye level with Buffy. "Go ahead. Touch them."
The blonde faltered for a moment then lifted her hand and lightly caressed the perfect breasts in front of her. Missy closed her eyes and moaned softly. Buffy could feel her own excitement grow as the cheerleader's nipples stiffened. She bent her head and gently sucked one.
"Oh fuck. That's it." Missy ran her fingers through Buffy's hair. "Let's put this down." She took the wine glass from the dazed girl and pushed her back on the bed. "Now let me touch yours." With that she pulled Buffy's top up.
Buffy sucked in her breath as Missy lowered her lips to Buffy's chest. "Oh my god!" She exclaimed, clinging tightly to the brunette as a flood of fluid soaked her pajama bottoms. She was so wet for Missy. "Um... Missy... I've never done this.." Anxiety crept in. What if she did something stupid? She really liked Missy and didn't want to spoil it.
"Don't worry. There's a first time for everything. Just let me drive." The Faith look-a-like spoke with confidence as she tugged Buffy's pajama bottoms down. Her hand cupped the blonde's soaked panties. "See, you're ready." She chuckled as she looked into the dark green eyes staring back at her. "I want to taste you." She whispered causing Buffy to groan.
"Uh... I don't know... I mean... Should we?" The slayer asked nervously, tears filling her eyes. "I really like you... and if we... I mean.."
"Buffy, what is it?" Missy kissed her softly on the lips. "What's wrong?"
"I don't just sleep with anyone. I like relationships." She finally managed to voice her concerns.
Missy grinned. "Normally, I don't... but with you... definitely yes. I want you to be my girlfriend. Will you?"
Buffy's eyes misted up. "Really? You do? I mean, yes. Yes, I want us to be girlfriends."
"Okay girlfriend." She kissed Buffy very tenderly again. "If you're too scared we can wait."
"Uh... what is it we do?" Buffy asked with uncertainty.
"I'll show you and if you don't like it, you can tell me to stop." Missy grinned as she slowly peeled off Buffy's panties.
"Okay." The blonde breathed out, shaking slightly. She held her breath as Missy leaned close.
"Come here, babe." Suddenly Missy stood up and grabbed Buffy's hand. She pulled a chair out and patted it. "Sit down B. Scoot to the edge and spread your legs."
The slayer could feel her cheeks burning as she did so. "Are you sure about this?"
"Oh yeah!" Missy kneeled in front of her and lowered her lips to Buffy's pussy.
"OH GOD!" Buffy almost arched off the chair at the contact. Missy gently held her still as she ran her tongue over Buffy wet slit and slowly circled her clit. "Oh Missy... that feels so... so... ahhhhhhh!"
Missy smiled as she lightly sucked on the slayer's clitoris. Buffy cried out, digging her nails into the cheerleader's shoulder. "More! Please... oh... more! YESSSSS!"
The brunette slipped a finger into Buffy and gently caressed the inner wall, quickly locating the small girl's g-spot. She smiled knowingly as she stroked it.
"OH MY GOD! OH MISSY! YOU HAVE TO STOP! OH YESSSS!... IT FEELS SO GOOD... AHHHHHHHHHH!" Buffy arched against the soft full lips, straining as she tensed and came into Missy mouth.
The brunette held her firmly against her face, eagerly licking up every drop. *Goddamn B, you're a hot one!* She continued to caresses the tiny blonde and lap at her until Buffy began to shake and came again. Missy stood and picked the slayer up, tossing her on the bed and climbing on top of her. "You're so frickin' hot! Do you know that?!" She grinned then laid a long, passionate kiss on Buffy's lips.
Buffy gave her a dazed smile. "I love you."
Missy chuckled. "I guess you came." When Buffy tried to sputter an explanation Missy stopped her. "Look it's okay and thank you, but it's too soon for me say that. I can say there's nowhere in the world I'd rather be than with you," she grinned a bit as she added, "girlfriend."
"That's enough for now." The Sunnydale slayer beamed. "But I still love you so I can wait."
"Deal." Missy rolled over and pulled Buffy on top of her. "I'm going to call my parents tomorrow. We'll go see Faith this weekend."
"I'm glad." Buffy snuggled up, happily. Then mumbled with a dreamy smile. "My girlfriend's a cheerleader."
"An ex-cheerleader, thank you."
"Oh please, try out for cheer again. It would be so sexy." Buffy begged. "Pleasssseee."
"Ugh! Alright... we'll see. You're going to be a handful, aren't you? " Missy kissed her and smiled, sighing, "Wait `til I tell Cliff."