Buffy Meets Cruel Intentions
by Shell
Rating: R
Willow picked up a cheery out of the bowl on the table beside the bed and ate it before asking "Am I supposed to feel this sore?" Faith looked up from writing in her journal.
"For the first time, yes." She began writing again "It’ll pass" Willow sat up on one elbow and started rubbing her hand up and down the inside of Faith’s thigh.
"I like it better when you use your tongue." Willow straddled her leaning in for a kiss when Faith pushed her off the bed.
"Willow this is what I like to call "quiet time". It’s the time when we reflect on the things we’ve just done."
"Sorry!" She said climbing back up on the bed. "Something wrong?"
"You think?"
"Is it me?"
"No you were fine."
"It’s that Buffy girl. You love her don’t you? It’s ok I don’t love you either." Willow said before fogging up Faith’s glasses by breathing on them. "I love Oz."
"I’m getting out of here."
"Where are you going?"
"I’m taking a shower."
"Want any company?"
"No."
"What me to go down on you?"
"Good night, Willow."
"Rude" she said before rolling back over and grabbing another cherry.
"Who are you spying on?" Cordy asked grabbing the binoculars from Faith.
"That her" she asked seeing Buffy reading a book.
"Yes."
"Oh no she’s crying. Little baby’s upset by the big bad book."
"Shut Up!" Faith said taking back the binoculars.
"What’s up your ass?"
"Nothing."
"She’s really getting to you, isn’t she?"
"If you must know yes." She said turning around. "I don’t know what to do. I can’t stand that "holier than thou" bullshit…yet I’m completely infatuated with her. She made me laugh." Cordy walked up behind her.
"So that’s why you’re losing our bet?"
"I’m not losing our bet." Faith answered turning around so her and Cordy were inches apart. "It’s just taking a little longer than I expected."
"Do you mind if I take my new car for a ride?" Cordy asked teasing Faith.
"Cordy the only thing you’re going to be riding is my hand. Now if you’ll excuse me I have some work to do." Faith said before leaving the room.
Buffy looked up from her book to see Faith coming towards her.
"Bon Jour madam mussel." Faith said kneeling and giving Buffy two pecks on her cheeks. She then ran small kisses down to her mouth before kissing her completely. She moved her hands to her waist. Buffy pushed her away.
"I’m sorry about that."
"I am too."
"You know what I’m not sorry I don’t take it back." Faith said turning back around.
"I thought we were just going to be friends."
"I can’t handle it. I can’t keep my feelings bottled up inside of me like you. Can you honestly tell me you feel nothing for me?"
"Yea I have feelings for you."
"Then what’s wrong? It’s not like you’re married."
"That’s not fair!"
"Why can’t we be together?"
"You really want to know why?"
"Yes, I wanna know why."
"It’s because I don’t trust myself with you." Buffy said getting up. They gazed at each other for a minute before Buffy turned and left. Faith just watched her go.
Buffy was brushing her hair when there was a knock on the door. "Come in." She answered before Faith walked in.
"Hi."
"I just came to say goodbye."
"Where are you going?"
"Back to the city. I may go to the south of France. I just can’t take your games anymore."
"What games?" Buffy asked getting up.
"Oh come off it. You’re hot one minute, you’re cold the next. You make me feel inadequate."
"Well I guess if that’s how you feel, then it’s best that you leave."
"Good for you." Faith said turning around and opening the door.
"Faith I don’t want us to part on bad terms."
"Well, I’m afraid you don’t have a choice in the matter." She said turning around and walking back over to Buffy. "You’re a hypocrite. I don’t associate with hypocrites."
"How am I a hypocrite?"
"Oh please Buffy you spend all your time preaching about "waiting for love". Here it is! Standing right in front of you. And you’re going to turn your back on it. So I guess we’re just fucked! I’ll move on. But you will spend the rest of your life…knowing that you’ve turned your back on love. That makes you a hypocrite. Have a nice life."
"Wait" Buffy walked over to Faith and locked the door. She gently pressed her mouth to Faith’s. Faith took the advantage and deepened the kiss pushing Buffy back to the bed. Buffy unbuttoned Faith’s jeans before laying on the bed her eyes never leaving Faith’s. She then unbuttoned her top.
"I’m sorry, I can’t" Faith said before leaving the room. Buffy buttoned her shirt back and started to cry.
"Get it together you pussy" Faith said into the mirror.
"Morning" Cordy said when Faith grabbed her arm.
"Morning."
"So how’d it go last night?" She asked straddling her.
"With who?"
"I know how it went with Willow. She won’t shut up about it."
"If you’re asking if I nailed her, the answer is no." Faith said closing her journal.
"She shot you down?"
"Exactly the opposite."
"What went wrong?"
"I don’t know. She was lying on the bed…ready to do it, but I was…I just didn’t feel right about it."
"You’re telling me you had the chance to fuck her and you didn’t? God are you a chump!" Faith sat up and grabbed Cordy by her ass to move her over.
"If you’re heading towards her room, you won’t find her."
"Where is she?"
"You don’t know. She left 30 minutes ago."
"Where did she go?"
"She apologized to your aunt and told her…she was going to stay with some friends. You blew it Faith. That girl’s come to her senses and will never come around you again."
"Stupid, stupid, stupid. Slayer. I’ll save that." Xander said going through his cd collection. "Hello."
"Xander it’s Spencer."
"Hey buddy."
"Is she with you?"
"No."
"Where is she?"
"I don’t know. Why don’t you leave her alone?"
"Where is she?" Faith screamed into her cell.
"She’s with her friend’s parents, the Smiths. She caught a train into Penn station 20 minutes ago."
"Thank you."
"No problem." Xander said before Faith hung up and continued to drive.
Buffy got onto the escalator and when she got to the top saw Faith standing there in a bright blue shirt.
"I’m impressed." Buffy said with a slight smile.
"Well I’m in love." Faith said before capturing her lips. They continued kissing for a little while before leaving the station.
"What’s with the music?" Buffy asked as she walked into the mansion with Faith.
"This is the love scene silly." Faith replied pulling Buffy over to the couch because when the scene starts they ain’t in the bedroom.
"Oh..Well I guess we shouldn’t keep our audience waiting then." Buffy said removing her clothes along with Faith’s.
"I guess not." Faith said looking at the woman in front of her before laying her down on the couch then lowering herself onto her.
"Hey why do you get to be on the top?" Buffy whined between kisses.
"Because that’s what it says in the script." Faith continued.
"Fuck the script!" Buffy said before pushing Faith onto the floor and climbing on top of her.
"Much rather you fuck me!" Faith replied after hitting the floor.
"I think I can do that." Buffy said before kissing Faith before she could say anything else. Since the talking was over Buffy began to caress Faith’s breast before moving down her body taking her time teasing Faith after all the script said to make it look hot!! Faith arched into Buffy trying to get more contact between their bodies. Buffy finally after much teasing slid two fingers into her. Faith moaned. Buffy pumped while her tongue teased her clit. She slipped a third finger in "Are you ok?" She asked. Faith just nodded. Faith screamed Buffy’s name as she came. Buffy finished up before climbing back up to capture Faith’s lips in her own.
"What happened to the music?" Faith asked after she got back her speech.
"It’s stopped it’s the end of the scene." Buffy said laying with Faith.
Faith gave Buffy a kiss before Buffy got into the limo to leave. Faith turned around and walked back in not noticing Cordy looking on from above.
Faith walked up the stairs to her house with a dozen roses in her hands. She adjusted the door man's tie before entering. She walked to her room before hearing moans coming from Cordy’s room. She placed the roses in the doorknob and turned to knock on the door.
"Just a minute." Cordy called from inside. There were a few noises before Faith knocked again. "Come in." Cordy said before Faith opened the door and walked in.
"Bad time?"
"Kinda"
"Well you obviously wanted me to witness your little adventure or else you wouldn’t have invited me in." Faith said before walking over to the bed. "Who is our friend who gives you such pleasure?" Cordy just looked up. "Where could he be?" Faith asked before pulling out the drawer under her bed.
"Hi" Oz said shaking a fuzzy bell. Faith looked back to Cordy. Oz got up and grabbed his clothes.
"There’s some fucked-up shit in this house." He said before leaving.
"Call me!" Cordy said waving. "You don’t get to have all the fun." Cordy said as Faith sat down on the bed.
"So I assume you’ve come here to make arrangements." She said running her hand over Faith’s thigh and bringing her mouth down over her breast.
"Some other time." Faith said getting up to leave.
"Excuse me?"
"I’m not in the mood." She said turning back around.
"I want to fuck!" Cordy screamed.
"And I don’t" Faith said turning to leave. "Good afternoon Cordy." She said before Cordy threw a glass at the door.
"Sounds great." Faith said into the phone. "I love you too." She said before putting down the receiver.
"I love you too?" Cordy said walking into the door. Faith was currently sitting on the edge of her desk. "My God! You’re completely pussy-whipped."
"Stop it!" Faith said getting up.
"What happened to us?"
"Nothing has changed."
"Yes it has. You love her. You don’t love me anymore."
"Come on Cordy, it’s just a bet." Cordy walked over and kissed Faith. Faith pushed her away.
"This is ridiculous!" She said walking away.
"What’s ridiculous dear sister is you!" Faith turned around to look at her. "Look at yourself. Look at what you’ve been reduced to. Have you given any thought about what will happen when school starts? Not only are you dating Miss Seventeen magazine, but she’s also the new headmaster’s daughter! Before you know it, you’ll be given campus tours with her. Wait. Her father doesn’t know about your past does he? I doubt he’d let his little princess be seen with the likes of you. It’s so disappointing to see that Buffy’s manifesto was a sham. As student body president, I feel it’s my sworn duty to tell him." Cordy said picking up the phone.
"Put the phone down."
"This will only take a second." Faith took the phone and slammed it down.
"Quite the predicament you’re in."
"I don’t care what you say." Faith said walking over to get her coat. "In fact, I was planning on telling her everything tonight."
"That’s right. I forgot. You’re so in love. Do you honestly believe that you’ve done a complete 180 in the few days you’ve known her? Well let me tell you something. People don’t change overnight. You and I are two of a kind. At least I have the guts to admit it. You were going to leave school a legend. Now you’re going to leave a joke."
"I’m willing to take my chances."
"Don’t do it Faith" Cordy said as Faith opened the door to leave. "You’ll not only ruin your reputation you’ll destroy hers." Faith left leaving Cordy siting there.
Faith walked down the street in thought before coming back that night and laying on the bed. She grabbed her journal and held it close before falling asleep.
The next morning she got out of her car and walked up to Buffy’s room. Buffy opened the door with a smile on her face. They exchanged "hi’s" before kissing.
"And this is my room." Buffy said giving Faith the tour of the house. "Do you think we can be quiet?"
"There’s something I have to tell you."
"Tell me."
"This isn’t working out for me anymore."
"Yeah, me neither." Buffy said leaning up to kiss her. "What’s wrong?" She asked when Faith didn’t respond to her kiss.
"It’s not you it’s me. I’m completely fucked up."
"What are you saying?" Buffy asked caressing her cheek.
"I thought I was in love with you, but it was just a lie. I wanted it to work, but unfortunately, I feel nothing."
"Why are you doing this?"
"I just wanted to see what you were like in bed."
"You don’t mean that."
"You know nothing. You don’t even know me. The fact of the matter is, there is someone I love. You don’t even compare to her."
"I don’t believe you." Buffy said with tears in her eyes.
"I don’t know how to make this any clearer to you. You mean nothing to me! You were just…you were just a conquest."
"You’re such a coward. Look at yourself! You’re shaking. Is that what you came to tell me?"
"I’m sorry. I’m completely—"
"Yeah you’re completely fucked up! Get out." Faith started to walk over to Buffy "Get out!" She put her hands on her. "Don’t touch me!" She screamed pushing Faith away. Faith kept trying. "Don’t fucking touch me Faith!" Buffy yelled. Buffy slapped her across her tear stained cheek. "Just leave." Faith turned and left leaving Buffy crying on the bed.
Cordy got out of her limo and handed her purse to the driver before taking off her jacket and walking into the house. She walked into her room and over to the bed not noticing Faith sitting in the chair on the other side of the room. "Jesus a little melodramatic don’t you think?" Cordy asked when she noticed her.
"I thought you’d like to know what happened between Buffy and I." Faith said removing her shades revealing her tear-stained cheek. "It’s over."
"Really?"
"You were right. I can’t change. You and I are two of a kind." Faith said before grabbing the bottle of champagne out of the bucket sitting beside her. "I thought we should celebrate."
"I’d love to…but unfortunately I’m expecting some company." Cordy said leaning on the bed.
"Who, Oz?"
"Not that it’s any of your business, but yes."
"From Oz" Faith said pulling an envelope out of her jacket. "I haven’t had a chance to read it yet, but I’m pretty sure it goes something like yada, yada, yada, you mean a lot to me. Hope we can still be friends, etc. etc. You see I expected your bullshit, so I took the liberty of arranging a little get-together between oz and Willow. You were right. You do get dumped for the innocent little twits." Faith said looking into the mirror to see Cordy.
"Well done."
"Thank you" Faith said grabbing 2 glasses and taking them over to the bed. "Now where were we? Oh yes the celebration." Faith said handing Cordy a glass. "What shall we toast to?"
"To my triumph."
"It’s not my choice of toasts, but it’s your call." Faith said looking at Cordy with a smile. "To your triumph over Buffy." Faith said before taking a drink. Cordy just started laughing. "What’s so funny?"
"Silly rabbit! My triumph isn’t over her. It’s over you," she said sitting down.
"Come again?"
"You were very much in love with her. And you’re still in love with her. But it amused me to make you ashamed of it. You gave up the first person you ever loved because I threatened your reputation. Don’t you get it? You’re just a toy Faith. A little toy I like to play with. And now you’ve complete blown it with her. I think it’s the saddest thing I’ve ever heard. Cheers!" Cordy said taking a drink. "Tastes good!" She put down her drink and walked over to her. "So I assume you’ve come here to make arrangements. But unfortunately, I don’t fuck losers." Cordy said to a battling Faith who just left the room. "Goodbye, Faith." Cordy said after the door slammed.
"It’s imperative that I talk to her." Faith said into the phone while pacing around her room.
"I don’t know what to tell you. She’s not here." The voice on the phone said.
"Could you please tell her I called?"
"Of course." She said before Faith slammed the phone down. She sat in her chair thinking before grabbing her journal.
"May I help you?" a lady asked when she opened the door and saw Faith.
"I need to speak with Buffy."
"She’s not here. Listen, I’m entertaining some guests—"
"Buffy, Buffy" Faith yelled.
"I already told you she’s not here."
"Could you please see that she gets this?" Faith said handing her the journal.
"I’ll do that."
"It’s really important."
"I understand. Good night." Faith walked down the hall and out of the building.
"I’m sorry about that. You never know who’s going to show up at my door."
Buffy walked into her room and sat on the bed before opening the envelope attached to the journal. "Dear Buffy, I don’t know what I can say to rectify the harm I’ve caused you. The truth of the matter is, being with you was the only time I’ve ever been happy. My whole life has been a joke. I prided myself on taking joy in other’s misery. Well, it finally backfired. I succeeded in hurting the first person I loved. Enclosed is my most prized possession: my journal. For a long time I considered it my trophy. A sort of collection of my conquests. If you really want to know the truth then please read it. No more lies. Please give me another chance. I’m a wreak without you." Buffy read Faith’s journal while Faith watched her from outside.
"Hello?" Oz answered the phone.
"Oz?" Cordy asked on the other end.
"Yea."
"It’s Cordy."
"What’s up? Is everything ok?"
"No it’s Faith. She’s out of her mind."
"What do you mean?"
"She hit me and took off. I’m just afraid to be alone. Please, I really need you."
"Ok just settle down."
"There’s more it involves Willow."
"Stay there I’ll be right over." Oz hung up the phone kissed Willow and left.
The next morning Faith got up and left from her spot outside Buffy’s window and headed down the street. Buffy looked out her window before leaving. Oz left Cordy’s house in a hurry. Buffy looked for Faith. Oz spotted Faith. "Son of a bitch!" He said before turning around. "Spencer."
"Hey Oz." Faith said turning around.
"We have some talking to do."
"Can we do it later? I’ve had a really bad night." Oz pushed Faith "What’s your problem?"
"Where do you come off, hitting Cordy."
"She got to you too."
"She told me everything."
"Oz you don’t know what you’re talking about."
"Yeas?"
"Yea!"
"She also told me you fucked Willow. It’s true isn’t it?"
"Oz I’m sorry."
"You fucke…" Oz started before punching Faith. Faith returned with a punch. But she was worn down from her long night and was taking a pretty bad beating. Buffy saw the fight and ran over. "Faith Faith." She yelled. "Stop it." She yelled attacking Oz, who threw her off and into the road. Faith looked up and saw a car coming before yelling "Buffy and running out into the road and throwing her out of the way. The car collided into her.
There was a bright flash of light before Faith woke up in her apartment. "What the hell was that?" She asked herself. Knowing there was one person that could tell her she got up and headed to Willow’s house.
Buffy awoke at the same time Faith did. "What was that?" She asked herself before getting dressed and heading to Willow’s.
"Red you here?" Faith asked knocking on the door to Willow’s room. Willow opened the door and stepped back for Faith to come in.
"What’s up?" She asked nervously.
"Well that’s what I’d like to know." Faith said before there was another knock at the door. Willow opened it to find Buffy standing there.
"Will, we need to…" Buffy trailed off when she saw Faith in the room. "Faith?"
"B" she answered knowing Buffy had been there too.
"Come in Buffy and we will talk about it." Willow said shutting the door behind her and getting ready to explain everything.
"Explain" Faith, said after they all were seated.
"Well you see umm…I kinda did a spell…"
"A spell?" Buffy practically screamed.
"B let her talk." Faith said wanting to get to the bottom of this.
"Yes..I did a spell to get you guys to talk and become friends, but something went wrong and you ended up stuck in a movie." Willow explained.
"We were in a movie?" Buffy asked.
"No you were acting out the events of a movie that you must have had a connection to and I’m guessing you two are the only ones that remember what happened kinda like a slayer dream." She tried to explain to the two girls.
"So you mean no one else knows about this?"
"Yes."
"But then how do you know what happened?" Faith asked slightly confused.
"Well since I cast the spell I kinda was like watching it." Willow said with a slight blush.
"Oh….Oh." Buffy said when she remembered everything that had happened. She turned to look at Faith who had a smile on her face.
"So you mean only us three knows what happened? Xander will never know he was with Spike and Cordy will never know what a bitch she was?" Faith asked leaving out the parts with her, willow, and Buffy.
"Yes." Willow stated.
"But if all of this really happened does that mean we actually slept together?" Faith asked Willow who was blushing furiously. By the blush on her face Faith knew the answer to that.
"But that means that we…oh" Buffy said as she finally realized everything actually happened.
"So this was just some spell gone wrong?" Faith asked Willow to get them out of the uncomfortable situation they were in.
"Not exactly."
"What do you mean?" Buffy asked.
"Everything that happened was things that everyone had bottled inside like emotions and secrets." Willow explained. "Like I was in love with Oz and all the other things."
"So you mean Xander and Spike want each other?" Faith asked with a grin.
"In a way." Willow explained.
"OHMYGOD!" Faith explained. "Who ever knew Xander, but with Spike."
"I know." Willow said while Buffy just sat there in thought.
"If everything that happened was a bottled emotion…that means you…" Buffy trailed off as she got up and ran from the room. Faith got up and followed her out.
Faith ran after Buffy trying to catch her. "B wait" she called when she saw her. Buffy finally stopped and turned to her. "Why’d you run out like that?" Faith asked when she caught her breath.
"I…I just didn’t know what to say it was all overwhelming." Buffy said between sobs.
"What was finding out that I love you or finding out we sleep together?" Faith asked seriously.
"Both."
"Oh" was all Faith could say.
"No…no" Buffy replied realizing what Faith thought she was saying. Faith looked up at her. "It’s not that I didn’t like it it’s just that I’m mad because it wasn’t actually us but it was if that makes sense." Buffy babbled.
"You mean…"
"Yes I love you and just took some messed up spell to realize it." Buffy said cupping Faith’s face.
"Let’s get out of here." Faith said taking Buffy’s hand and leaving the graveyard they ended up in.
Xander walked through the graveyard heading toward an all too familiar place. Tonight I’m going to let him know how I feel, he thought walking up to the crypt.
"What?" Spike said as he opened the door. "Xander co…." He was cut off by Xander’s lips on his. Spike pulled him into the crypt shutting the door behind them.
"What do you…" Cordy started before being cut off by Willow’s mouth on her own.
"Sorry I just always wanted to do that." Willow said before leaving a stunned Cordy on the doorstep.
Faith led Buffy into her hotel room and shut the door. The minute the door was shut Buffy attacked Faith’s lips with her own. "Do you know how long I’ve wanted this?" Buffy asked.
"Well if I remember right I never got to repay you the favor." Faith said before laying Buffy on the bed.
...continued in Cruel Intentions Meets Buffy...